Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions
The tag alias #81660 mario_&_luigi:_bowser's_inside_story -> bowser's_inside_story is pending approval.
Reason: They are both copyright tags for the exact same game, some posts use different versions of the tag and it was difficult to find an art I wanted to share when I was searching under "mario_&_luigi:_bowser's_inside_story" but it was only tagged under "bowser's_inside_story"
Reverse it in favor of the actual title.
The bulk update request #13156 is pending approval.
create alias bowser's_inside_story (151) -> mario_&_luigi:_bowser's_inside_story (13) # has blocking transitive relationships, cannot be applied through BUR
create implication mario_&_luigi:_bowser's_inside_story (13) -> mario_and_luigi_(series) (1251)
create implication partners_in_time (99) -> mario_and_luigi_(series) (1251)
create implication superstar_saga (115) -> mario_and_luigi_(series) (1251)
Reason: ^Flipped and I think it should imply mario_and_luigi_(series)
lafcadio said:
Reverse it in favor of the actual title.
long tag names like that can cause formatting issues on the tag list and elsewhere, so I believe that we generally leave the series title out unless the title of the individual piece of media would potentially be ambiguous. for example, the tag for The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild is just breath_of_the_wild.
I don't think it's likely that we're likely to see any other piece of media with the title "Bowser's Inside Story", so there's not much of a reason to have the series title included.
dba_afish said:
long tag names like that can cause formatting issues on the tag list and elsewhere, so I believe that we generally leave the series title out unless the title of the individual piece of media would potentially be ambiguous. for example, the tag for The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild is just breath_of_the_wild.I don't think it's likely that we're likely to see any other piece of media with the title "Bowser's Inside Story", so there's not much of a reason to have the series title included.
Is that a thing? Here's some *:_* tags that use the long name:
mao_mao:_heroes_of_pure_heart
paper_mario:_the_thousand_year_door
dragon_quest:_the_adventure_of_dai
captain_laserhawk:_a_blood_dragon_remix
konosuba:_god's_blessing_on_this_wonderful_world!
five_nights_at_freddy's:_security_breach_ruin
For length comparison:
mario_&_luigi:_bowser's_inside_story
crocogator said:
Is that a thing? Here's some *:_* tags that use the long name:[...]
yeah, and most of those have reasons for being like that:
dba_afish said:
yeah, and most of those have reasons for being like that:
- mao_mao:_heroes_of_pure_heart, captain_laserhawk:_a_blood_dragon_remix, konosuba:_god's_blessing_on_this_wonderful_world!
- these are just the full titles of the entire series, not the subtitle for an entry in said seires
- and in the first two cases they'd also be ambiguous without the subtitles, since those are character names
- (and in Mao Mao's case his name is literally just cat sounds, so not exactly unambiguous as-is)
- paper_mario:_the_thousand_year_door:
- not implicated
- notably the shorter the_thousand_year_door tag is aliased away just to paper_mario
- five_nights_at_freddy's:_security_breach_ruin:
- this would be kinda ambiguous without the full title the base game obviously couldn't have the tag just security_breach, since that's a generic term, and security_breach_ruin might be fine, but ehh...
Fair point. Neither partners_in_time nor superstar_saga has mario_&_luigi:. (I gotta include both of them in my BUR later.)
Perhaps the first alias is fine.
