Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions
The bulk update request #2182 is pending approval.
create implication dagger (4631) -> knife (16631)
create implication holding_dagger (609) -> holding_knife (2570)
create implication holding_dagger (609) -> holding_weapon (51273)
Reason: A dagger is a knife. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dagger?wprov=sfti1
Since not all knives are necessarily weapons, but a dagger is, holding_dagger should also imply holding_weapon.
Rather make a bladed weapon tag.
aaronfranke said:
Does this mean that sword is also a knife?
No, a knife is specifically a short blade. Swords are longer than knives. From Wikipedia:
Dagger:
A dagger is a knife with a very sharp point and usually two sharp edges, typically designed or capable of being used as a thrusting or stabbing weapon.
Sword:
Its blade, longer than a knife or dagger, is attached to a hilt and can be straight or curved.
furrin_gok said:
Rather make a bladed weapon tag.
I could add that to the BUR. It can’t be implied through knife, as not all knives are weapons, but dagger can share the tag with swords, axes, most polearms, and other weapon knives.
On the other hand, dagger and sword both already imply melee weapon, and I’m not sure that we need a bladed weapon subset of that. With a few exceptions, most melee weapons have blades already.
furrin_gok said:
Rather make a bladed weapon tag.
And maybe clean up and implicate blade?
scaliespe said:
Reason: A dagger is a knife. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dagger?wprov=sfti1
Since not all knives are necessarily weapons, but a dagger is, holding_dagger should also imply holding_weapon.
Good points.
