Topic: Tag implication: kaiju_paradise -> roblox

The tag implication #71104 kaiju_paradise -> roblox is pending approval.

Reason: Roblox game with distinctly blocky avatars and "robloxian" character designs.

forum #349142

fluffysoup said:
forum #349142

I disagree with that reply. dandy's_world already implies roblox despite being one of the games it'd apply to the least. The other games at the very least have distinctly roblox aspects (avatar appearance for ex) which I think would validate an implication.

plushbone said:
I disagree with that reply. dandy's_world already implies roblox

That's... literally the only thing that implies roblox, feels like an unfair exception to me. Besides, by that logic, we should imply EVERY youtuber and yt videos on this site to youtube, which is just impractical

edit: not to mention the fact that games (from roblox or not) could be in any platforms as the developer chooses

whatismyname1234 said:
That's... literally the only thing that implies roblox, feels like an unfair exception to me. Besides, by that logic, we should imply EVERY youtuber and yt videos on this site to youtube, which is just impractical

edit: not to mention the fact that games (from roblox or not) could be in any platforms as the developer chooses

I think a good solution is only implicating games that directly reference roblox itself and are on the platform (ex. forsaken, phighting, block_tales, etc). I'm not sure why dandy's world implies it when by all intents and purposes it shouldn't, if everything else doesn't.

The youtube comparison (and by extension the steam comparison) doesn't work because youtube videos and steam games have little to do with the platforms they're hosted on. A video can exist as it's own mp4 separate from youtube. Alot of roblox games can't, because they use the roblox avatars, characters from roblox, items from roblox, etc.

plushbone said:
I think a good solution is only implicating games that directly reference roblox itself and are on the platform (ex. forsaken, phighting, block_tales, etc). I'm not sure why dandy's world implies it when by all intents and purposes it shouldn't, if everything else doesn't.

The youtube comparison (and by extension the steam comparison) doesn't work because youtube videos and steam games have little to do with the platforms they're hosted on. A video can exist as it's own mp4 separate from youtube. Alot of roblox games can't, because they use the roblox avatars, characters from roblox, items from roblox, etc.

fair enough

The bulk update request #13169 is active.

remove implication dandy's_world (1124) -> roblox (3284)

Reason:

plushbone said:
I think a good solution is only implicating games that directly reference roblox itself and are on the platform (ex. forsaken, phighting, block_tales, etc). I'm not sure why dandy's world implies it when by all intents and purposes it shouldn't, if everything else doesn't.

Let's remove it then.

EDIT: The bulk update request #13169 (forum #479642) has been approved by @spe.

The bulk update request #13169 (forum #479642) has been approved by @spe.